The Heat Treat Doctor® has returned to offer sage advice to Heat Treat Today readers and to answer your questions about heat treating, brazing, sintering, and other types of thermal treatments as well as questions on metallurgy, equipment, and process-related issues.
Clients often want to know or specify that their component part surfaces are “bright” or “shiny” or “clean.” Other times they desire to have a surface condition that is “scale free” or “oxide free” after heat treatment. But how, if at all, can we quantify what these terms mean? Let’s learn more.
“Shiny” and “bright” are words that are highly subjective. This is often a source of confusion not only for the heat treater, but the manufacturer and, in some cases, even the end user of the products. Heretofore, the answer depended on one human being’s interpretation as opposed to another, and evaluations depend not only on the type of material but also the mill practices used, manufacturing methods employed, heat treatment processes, and the level and type of contamination introduced before and after processing.
Traditional Approach
Traditionally, we have relied on color charts (Figure 1) to tell the approximate temperature at which discoloration took place, that is, an oxide formed on the (steel, stainless steel, or tool steel) surface of a component part. This method is still in use today when cooling parts in a furnace
As mentioned, the perception and interpretation of color is different for different people. Lighting (natural light or plant illumination), the environment in which one views color, eye fatigue, the age of the observer, and a host of other factors influences color perception. But even without such physical considerations, each of us interprets color based on personal perception. Each person also verbally describes an object’s color differently. As a result, objectively communicating a particular color to another person without using some type of standard is difficult.
There also must be a way to compare one color to the next with accuracy.
New Approach
Today, portable spectrophotometers (Figure 2) are available to measure color and help quantify brightness measurements. These types of devices are designed to meet various industry standards including:
- Whiteness (e.g., ASTM E313, CIE)
- Gray scale (e.g., ISO 105 staining, color change)
- Opacity (e.g., contrast ratio, Tappi strength — SWL, Summed, Weighted Sum)
- Yellowness (e.g., ASTM E313, D1925)
In simplest terms, a spectrophotometer is a color measurement device used to capture and evaluate color. Every object has its own reflectance, or the amount of light it reflects, and transmittance, or the amount of light it absorbs. A reflectance spectrophotometer shines a beam of light and measures the amount of light reflected from different wavelengths of the visible spectrum, while a transmission spectrophotometer measures how much light passes through the sample. Spectrophotometers can measure and provide quantitative analysis for just about anything, including solids, liquids, plastics, paper, metal, fabric, and even painted samples to verify color and consistency.
Spectrophotometers provide the solution to the subjective problem of interpreting the color of the surface of a component part that has been heat treated, brazed, or sintered because they explicitly identify the colors being measured; that is, the instrument differentiates one color from another and assigns each a numeric value.
As an example, the brightness of steel tubes annealed in a rich Exothermic gas atmosphere was measured against tubes that had not been processed (Figure 3). Having this definite measurement of the surface changes allowed the heat treater to provide their client with a definitive statement on the change after processing.
CIE Color Systems
The Commission Internationale de l’Eclairage (CIE) is an organization responsible for international recommendations for photometry and colorimetry. The CIE standardized color order systems include specifying the light source (illumination), the observer, and the methodology used to derive values for describing color, regardless of industry or use case.
Though spectrophotometers are the most common, for some applications colorimeters can also be used, but these are in general less accurate and less suitable for a heat treat environment.
There are three primary types of spectrophotometers on the market today used for print, packaging, and industrial applications: traditional 0°/45° (or 45°/0°) spectrophotometers, primarily used for the print industry; sphere (or diffuse/8°) spectrophotometers, primarily used in the packaging industry; and multi-angle (MA) spectrophotometers, for use in industrial environments. These instruments capture color information, and in some cases can capture appearance data (e.g., gloss).
Multi-angle (MA) spectrophotometers are best suited for measurements involving special surface effects, such as those found on metal surfaces and coatings and include those with surface contaminants and even can quantify cosmetic appearance. These are typically used on the shop floor, in the lab and in quality control, and even can be found in shipping areas.
MA spectrophotometers require users to verify five or more sets of L*a*b values or delta these terms). They typically have an aperture size of 12 mm, which is too large for measuring the fine detail that occurs in many small-scale industrial applications. Primary illumination is provided at a 45° angle. Some models have secondary illumination at a 15° angle.
An application example for an MA spec trophotometer lies in their use for collecting colorimetric data on special effects coatings in the automotive industry, capturing reliable color data in cases where special effect coatings are used.
Final Thoughts
In this writer’s opinion, a spectrophotometer should be in every heat treat shop! You will be doing both yourself and your customers a valuable service and take the guesswork out of one of the most commonly asked questions – is it bright?
References
- Herring, Dan H. Atmosphere Heat Treatment Volume 1. BNP Media, 2014.
- X-Rite Pantone. “A Guide to Understanding Color.” Accessed October 10, 2024. https://www.xrite.com/learning-color-education/whitepapers/a-guide-to-understanding-color.
- X-Rite Panatone. “Tolerancing Part 3: Color Space vs. Color Tolerance.” Accessed October 10, 2024. https://www.xrite.com/blog/tolerancingpart-3.
- X-Rite Pantone. “X-Rite Portable Multi Angle Spectrophotometers.” Accessed October 10, 2024. https://www.xrite.com/categories/portable-pectrophotometers/ma-family.
About the Author
“The Heat Treat Doctor”
The HERRING GROUP, Inc.
Dan Herring has been in the industry for over 50 years and has gained vast experience in fields that include materials science, engineering, metallurgy, new product research, and many other areas. He is the author of six books and over 700 technical articles.
For more information: Contact Dan at dherring@heat-treat-doctor.com.
For more information about Dan’s books: see his page at the Heat Treat Store.
